You’ve earned it — after all your hard work and focus, relax and recharge with a perfect getaway at stayshostel.com or stayshostelclub.com.
BUY BUY Duplex / 2-family $1,075,000 Asking price · $416.34 per square fo View Watchlist >
Preliminary estimated value $1,025,000–$1,125,000
Notice : ( 4%Buyer Broker's fee) include in the sale .
Item # 423791
Start Date
End Date
0 Watching
Comparative market analysis – 000 Garfield Avenue, Mineola, NY 11501
Active listingDuplex / 2-family
$1,075,000
Asking price · $416.34 per square foot
Based on the listing information, this property should be evaluated as both an owner-occupied two-family home and an investment property.
1. Investment analysis
|
Item |
Amount |
|---|---|
|
Asking price |
$1,075,000 |
|
First-floor monthly rent |
$3,500 |
|
Second-floor monthly rent |
$3,000 |
|
Combined monthly rent |
$6,500 |
|
Annual gross rent |
$78,000 |
|
Annual property taxes |
$14,413 |
|
Annual rent less property taxes |
$63,587 |
|
Gross rental yield |
7.26% |
The $63,587 figure is before insurance, maintenance, water, vacancy, capital expenditures, and other operating expenses.
The property has several attractive features:
-
Two separate residential units.
-
Two electric meters and two gas meters.
-
Tenants reportedly responsible for gas and electricity.
-
Three-car driveway and garage.
-
Finished basement and updated kitchens.
-
Walking distance to Mineola LIRR station and NYU Langone Hospital.
2. Comparable sold properties in Mineola
The following are particularly relevant sales, using publicly available 2025–2026 transaction information.
|
Comparable property |
Sold price |
Details |
|---|---|---|
|
236 Jackson Avenue |
$950,000 |
4 BR, 2 BA, 1,384 sq. ft. |
|
41 Jackson Avenue |
$1,150,000 |
6 BR, 3 BA, 2,210 sq. ft. |
|
160 Garfield Avenue #2 |
$930,000 |
2-family, 3 BR, 2 BA, 1,710 sq. ft. |
|
47 Jackson Avenue |
$1,150,000 |
9 BR, 4 BA, 3,500 sq. ft. |
|
84 2nd Street #80 |
$623,000 |
Legal 2-family, sold as-is |
+4
Most relevant comparisons
236 Jackson Avenue
$950,000
4 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms · 1,384 sq. ft.
Sold July 10, 2026. Particularly relevant because it has the same two-bedroom-per-unit configuration.
Redfin
41 Jackson Avenue
$1,150,000
6 bedrooms · 3 bathrooms · 2,210 sq. ft.
Sold March 11, 2026. Larger bedroom count, finished basement and two-car garage.
MLS ID 903321
160 Garfield Avenue
$930,000
3 bedrooms · 2 bathrooms · 1,710 sq. ft.
Sold August 28, 2025. Very useful location comparison because it is on the same street. However, it needed updates.
MLS ID 858349
3. Estimated market value of 000 Garfield Avenue
Considering:
-
Its 2,582 square feet of living area.
-
Updated condition and kitchens.
-
Two rental units.
-
Finished basement.
-
Garage and driveway parking.
-
Proximity to Mineola LIRR.
-
Rental income of $6,500 monthly.
My preliminary opinion is that the asking price of $1,075,000 is within a defensible market range.
Preliminary estimated value
$1,025,000–$1,125,000
Indicative valuation, not a formal appraisal
My suggested value: approximately $1,075,000.
I would consider an asking price of $1,075,000 reasonable, subject to verification of the property's legal configuration, condition and comparable sale adjustments.
4. Comparable property locations
5. Important items to verify before purchasing
-
Legal two-family status: Confirm the certificate of occupancy permits both apartments.
-
Basement: Verify that the finished basement is legally usable for the advertised purposes and is not being counted as additional living space.
-
Attic: Verify permitted use and access.
-
Rents: Confirm whether $3,500 and $3,000 are actual leases or projected rental values.
-
Taxes: Verify the $14,413 annual tax figure and any pending reassessment.
-
Building condition: Inspect the 1908 foundation, roof, plumbing, electrical and heating systems.
My recommendation
At $1,075,000, this property deserves serious consideration. The same-street sale at 160 Garfield Avenue for $930,000 and the sale at 41 Jackson Avenue for $1,150,000 provide useful valuation reference points.
There are no questions for this listing.